Why not pay out a portion of the tax recovered from audits as a bonus. The IRS auditor gets 1-10% of the tax they recover for the people of the USA.
It'd work like the commissions the big accounting firms receive of the amount of tax they save for their clients.
I bet there'd be a benefit in retaining those really smart auditors who could pass all the tests as well. I can't help but imagine some of those auditors leave the IRS and go straight to those aforementioned accounting firms. Farm team style like the Senators and Representatives do to lobbyists.