> The phone company makes sure your new phone has the same phone number
This is exactly why 2-factor SMS is insecure. You mention later that email is something you know, instead of something you have. In the same way, if a company can transfer my number to a new phone without access to the original phone, then it's not really something I have.
The ease of number transfers are the problem. The reason why 2FA tokens aren't stored online and secured with a password is because they are designed to be something you have, not something you know.
For comparison, switching your number to Verizon only requires information that you know (account numbers, a SSN)[0], so it's just extra steps around a less secure password that you can't change or set yourself.
> But then isn't that just one factor instead of two factors
Expanding on the above -- yes, email is often going to be just another account secured with another password. In practice, hacking two accounts is often harder than hacking one, and in practice, I suspect breaking into someone's Gmail account is harder than stealing their phone number. Google offers much more comprehensive 2FA options than most other companies, and their automated security alerts also tend to be better.
But there's no reason for us to debate over how secure email is.
The situation we have today with companies like Amazon/Facebook/Twitter is one where I can already request a password reset without SMS. Companies are scared of strict 2FA methods because customers get locked out of their accounts. Very, very few of them are willing to take that risk, so email will virtually always be an option. SMS is being added on top of that system -- it's not replacing it.
Here's Twitter's account recovery help page[1]:
> If you do not receive anything back, get help with Twitter via SMS or use the email password reset option.
So if you consider email to be a weak link in identity verification/2FA, adding SMS verification as a secondary option alongside email still doesn't do anything to increase your security. In fact, even if SMS was as secure as email, forcing you to monitor two authentication methods instead of just one would still be less secure.
I'm not advocating email is perfect, I'm just advocating that SMS is less secure than email, and that since companies are already comfortable trusting email, they can continue to rely on that.
Of course if you really want to set up 2FA to literally be 'something you have', then you need to accept that things you have can be lost. And if you're not willing to make that compromise, at least email accounts are harder to hack than phone numbers, because the most common email providers are probably more resistant than Verizon to social engineering attacks.
[0]: https://www.verizonwireless.com/support/local-number-portabi...
[1]: https://help.twitter.com/en/managing-your-account/forgotten-...