And the rest of the article is about a test with crash dummies. Why would the author talk about "people" when the tests were performed with dummies?
And the rest of the article is about a test with crash dummies. Why would the author talk about "people" when the tests were performed with dummies?
Because the upshot of the tests is that if your car is equipped with ACAS that "detects pedestrians," then it may lull you into a false sense that your car will avoid running people over and killing them even if you stop paying attention. The reality is that the ACAS is not foolproof and you shouldn't rely on it. But these systems are likely to create a Volvo Effect, where the people who have them drive much more recklessly than people without them.
Hard hypothesis to test. Just stay away from Volvo’s.
If you want to "stay way from Volvos" on account of it, fine. Please also consider throwing a pinch of salt over your shoulder when you spill it, and crossing the street when you see a black cat.
From the article:
Tesla: 20 tests, 20 kills - 0% success
Chevy Malibu:20 tests, 20 kills - 0% success
Honda Accord: 20 tests, 4 kills - 80% success
Toyota Camry: 20 tests, 12 kills - 40% success
There were other tests (also failed) but the article didn't give full details on those so I won't include them here.
Looking at that, one manufacturer has a product that works poorly and three manufacturers should probably face sanctions for selling their "product" in a US marketplace.
It's hard to compare because people and machines fail in different ways. Machines don't really know what people look like or how they behave, and are easily misled. People get drunk, get tired, get angry, look at their phones, and generally get confused. Humans have remarkable talents for putting together a 3D scene with only two eyes, but those eyes are extremely restricted in the range of wavelengths they perceive.
If we get aggressive in shutting down the cause of accidents, we're going to ban cars entirely. The machines are far from perfect; they may even be far from good. But the machines are getting better, and humans are getting worse.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Risk_compensation
That has been borne out with studies of how people adjust to airbags, SUVs, pickups, and other vehicles they emotionally perceive as being safe.
One of the things I've read about risk compensation is that it has very little correlation to the actual safety of a vehicle, and a lot of correlation to certain features that people emotionally associate with safety.
For example, modern automobiles are safer when they provide plenty of rear visibility. However, many inexperienced drivers feel safer when cocooned in opaque materials, so they feel safer in vehicles with less glass. It feels to them like they're wrapped in protective steel.
Likewise, in a previous era people felt safer in longer vehicles, even if those same longer vehicles were less maneuverable and therefore more likely to get into an accident in the first place.
Length of vehicle is highly visible, the ability to avoid an accident is not.