Enterpreneurs don't "give" jobs to people. Refer to the "wage labour" definition:
> Wage labour is the socioeconomic relationship between a worker and an employer, where the worker sells their labour power under a formal or informal employment contract.
precisely, they're purchasing labor. And actually, Bezos is puchasing it at a dirty cheap price.
A job is better than no job. Bezos hired them to do something productive.
[0] https://www.cnbc.com/2019/07/10/amazon-reveals-the-truth-on-...
[1] https://nypost.com/2019/05/27/amazon-is-reportedly-eyeing-of...
NYC doesn't seem like it's struggling to attract jobs.
While also destroying jobs in the retail sector as brick and mortar stores are closing shop.
> Do you really want to disincentivize what he does for humanity?
This is such a broad question to directly answer. But in my opinion, a big part of Amazon's success has been at the expense of dozens of retail companies (Macy's stock price was $50+ 5 years ago, today it's $15, and the same trend exists for just about every large retailer).
I'm sure a lot of people will disagree, but I much prefer an economy with many smaller companies competing in the market instead of one giant company controlled by 1 person dominating everything. I think the government should do more to incentivize healthy market competition (which Amazon is not), BUT I don't think the solution to that is more taxes..
Yes, I would like to "disincentivize" this.
This is why high tax proponents are never satisfied: we can raise all kinds of rates, but there's always some tax that a "rich" (which is never well defined) person is not paying enough of.
But even more to the point is that that only way you can calculate that someone earning $15,000 a year is paying a “higher tax rate” than someone earning $15 million a year is by ignore the fact that the person earning $15k is year is getting EITC, food, and health care subsidies and has an effective negative tax rate even if they did actually pay a few hundred dollars in sales taxes.
Here is a good analysis on average tax rates and effective marginal tax rates across income deciles:
https://fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/R44787.pdf
Note that average effective tax rate is negative up through the 4th decile. (Figure 2)
There are points along the curve where the effective marginal tax rate for a mid-range income earner is higher than the effective marginal tax rate of a high income earner. This is due to phase-out of transfer credits — specifically, ACA credits phasing out. (Figure 7) Specifically what that means is you earn an extra dollar and in addition to it being taxed at e.g. 25% it also causes you to lose .25 of ACA credits, making the effective tax rate on that $1 be 50%.
In a competitive market with low switching costs, workers get paid roughly what their work is worth. It’s government’s function to ensure the market is competitive and the switching costs are low.
But a competitive market with low switching costs does not guarantee that every worker is capable of performing at the median in terms of value creation. In fact it’s a mathematical impossibility.
So in perfectly competitive market with a progressive taxation model, lower income earners will be subsidized by the higher income earners, despite everyone being paid entirely competitive and appropriate wages for their individual contributions.
It’s not the employers responsibility to subsidize below-median earners, because they aren’t the ones collecting the surplus from the above-median earners.
I personally think that most of these subsidies shouldn’t ever phase out, specifically because they screw over the middle class with punitive marginal tax rates. The net effect is that you still cross from negative to positive effective taxes at some point, but it happens with a much smoother marginal tax rate versus gross income.
A completely different discussion is whether employers should be able to hire very low skilled workers to do menial jobs at very low pay, or whether we should force employers to provide training and support to employees to the point where they can perform enough valuable work to justify some minimum wage, and everything else just needs to be automated away.
This I disagree with emphatically. The empoyers benefit from the social structure supported by tax dollars.
Could you imagine a starting a business in the wilderness with no transportation, utilities or other community supported infrastructure ?
Those companies also put the most wear and tear on the infrastructure.
Now we have the infrastructure and the economy, from which the government collects ~$6.5 trillion each year.
Companies hire people and pay them for the jobs they perform. In general, more valuable jobs pay higher salaries. The whole thing is a virtuous cycle. Without companies paying salaries, no consumers are buying products from those companies, and so on.
In the end, all of the $6.5 trillion comes from people living here. Whether it’s payroll taxes, income taxes, excise taxes, business profit taxes, usage fees,... it’s people paying these taxes out of their personal bank account, or out of a corporate bank account which is in turn owned by the shareholders of that company.
Generally increasing the tax rate on a company just increases the price of that conpany’s goods on the market. The customers of the company pay, or the company goes out of business.
The infrastructure is there so that companies can use it to hire employees, sell goods & services provided by their employees, grow the economy, increase payroll, and generate more tax revenue.
The tax structure is designed around redistribution of wealth. It does not follow that therefore somehow employers are underpaying their employees.
There have been cases where employers have colluded to keep wages below market. The government should prosecute those cases and fine those companies.
And like I said, if we want a minimum wage, that’s fine, but what it’s setting is a floor on the marginal value of an employee that is hireable, and anyone below that threshold becomes un-hireable.