My sense is that yeah there's Amazon and all the other missed opportunities, but don't they also have some corporate raider type as CEO who's totally cashing in on running this chain into the ground?
My sense is that yeah there's Amazon and all the other missed opportunities, but don't they also have some corporate raider type as CEO who's totally cashing in on running this chain into the ground?
Institutional Investor tried to answer that question in http://institutionalinvestor.com/article/b1c33fqdnhf21s/Eddi.... Their take:
"… ESL hasn’t lost the entire $1.5 billion it invested in Sears and Kmart equity. Including the gains and losses on the major spin-offs, dividends, and interest income, it appears that loss was narrowed to about $624 million. Adding back the $2 billion in gains from hedge fund fees would give Lampert a net profit of approximately $1.38 billion. And that’s not even counting the uncertain value of his $2.6 billion in Sears debt, with its liens on Sears real estate, among other items."
Industry consensus is that no one would have chosen to make this investment if they knew what the next 10 years would look like, but given those abysmal results, he did far better than any other stakeholder.
IIRC he's kind of an extreme libertarian who actively pitted different parts of the company against each other, to compete.
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2013-07-11/at-sears-...
> Lampert runs Sears like a hedge fund portfolio, with dozens of autonomous businesses competing for his attention and money. An outspoken advocate of free-market economics and fan of the novelist Ayn Rand, he created the model because he expected the invisible hand of the market to drive better results. If the company’s leaders were told to act selfishly, he argued, they would run their divisions in a rational manner, boosting overall performance.
> Instead, the divisions turned against each other—and Sears and Kmart, the overarching brands, suffered. Interviews with more than 40 former executives, many of whom sat at the highest levels of the company, paint a picture of a business that’s ravaged by infighting as its divisions battle over fewer resources.
> Under the new model, Lampert evaluated the different divisions—and calculated executives’ bonuses—using a metric called business operating profit, or BOP. As some employees had feared, individual business units started to focus solely on their own profitability and stopped caring about the welfare of the company as a whole. According to several former executives, the apparel division cut back on labor to save money, knowing that floor salesmen in other departments would inevitably pick up the slack. Turf wars sprang up over store displays. No one was willing to make sacrifices in pricing to boost store traffic.
Grocery stores sell milk as a loss because people look at the price of milk and buy from the cheapest - then buy the high margin cereal, candy (or whatever is high margin) that more than makes up for the loss in milk. This can still be short term thinking, and yet result in the whole doing well over the long term.
Short-term thinking is letting your stores fall apart to boost profits, ignoring the exponentially long-term costs of a lack of maintenance.
They were a European powerhouse who came to North America, launching in Canada first, and then in the US when they had used the Canadian launch to sort out doing business in North America.
The Canadian unit paid a big consulting firm to build an online banking app. Fine.
When they launched in the US, the Canadians didn't want the US unit to have the banking app. Why? Because management at Trappist Financial stack-ranked its business units against each other, so if you help another unit, your bonuses will suffer.
There was a protracted fight, and eventually the US unit got the source code in one big lump. However, the consultants that had built the app were forbidden to do any work for the US unit, thus the firm I worked for were parachuted in to take over.
Development diverged, with both Canada and the US adding new features, but the code forked and neither unit would share its additions with the other unit. So there was much duplication of features, and zero knowledge-sharing.
It's not for me to say whether this made La Trappe Financial more successful overall, but I can say that I witnessed a great deal of wasted engineering and lost opportunities that everyone attributed to the perverse incentives created when units compete with each other rather than collaborate.
I imagine that they only way they would have cooperated on a project like internet banking would be if someone was savvy enough to create the illusion that only by cooperating could they beat Germany, or A/NZ, or Japan, &c.
What a colossal waste.
Another example I can think of is Microsoft under Ballmer; they operated that way to a certain extent. It didn't work out too great for them either, but they were a monopoly of sorts, so they had the luxury of being able to operate that way without it killing them.
It’s just the nature of ideologues to think this way; you don’t become an ideologue by practicing pragmatism.
Now this all makes sense. I used to shop there and sometimes the entire floor was devoid of staff to help you except the one person ringing up at the counter. It became too depressing to shop there at some point.
I can't remember seeing anyone defend him much anywhere, and even though I don't think much of libertarianism and Rand these days, it would be interesting to read a defense by someone who was reasonably intelligent and had done some research beyond just listening to the stuff everyone repeats. I have a feeling that even though his management may have been destructive, the stories are greatly simplified and distorted to make good stories.