2. "maybe we just sent a weird password to HR, and they did the default thing and fired the guy"
You just acknowledged in the prior paragraph that an actual complaint was necessary.
"years later we remember the justification that he must have deserved it because he's gone. (Details? Sorry, can't!)"
To be clear, you have already said you have no basis whatsoever to believe that he made up the details that justified the firing.
Just like I could suggest, with no basis, that you actually dumped your ex-girlfriend in a mean and nasty way over her struggles with addiction, and while distraught over the breakup she expressed her displeasure with you in conversations with mutual friends. You weren't actually present at any of these conversations, but you're sure she called you schizophrenic, satanic, and a creep, details you made up because it's easier on your conscience. You were the only person who ever perceived her as "frenzied", her job never did and neither would the cops, but it's easier on your conscience to say the only reason you didn't get a restraining order was to keep her out of jail.
All that would be entirely consistent with the facts you've told us, if I wanted to view you in the worst possible light with no basis whatsoever. Just like you're doing to jedberg.