Teaching Ethics in Appalachia Taught Me About Bridging America’s Partisan Divide
politico.com
politico.com
The author has a Juris Doctor, not a PhD. Presumably the issue was not with the subject of study, but with the level of the degree. No offense to JDs (I have one also), but it's not the same thing as a PhD.
IMO, the author tells this anecdote in a way that could be read as stereotyping Southern/rural colleges: "they love their religion, but not lawyers". In reality, it was probably just a PhD requirement. But that doesn't make for a seemingly-counterintuitive anecdote.
But my point was more that it's very reasonable for a college to require that all instructors have PhDs, and JDs (3 yrs) are not PhDs (5 yrs).
I have always found it odd that one can graduate from a law school and then immediately turn around and begin teaching law students. This is true also for PhDs and PhD students, but there is more temporal separation between first-year students and just-graduated professors because the degree typically takes 5+ years.
I wonder though --- why do you think it's reasonable that a college would require a PhD from all instructors? Why not simply consider the degree to be a plus, but not a requirement? Do you restrict this to "all" instructors in fields where a PhD is common? Would you eliminate artists or authors from teaching creative courses with (or without) an MFA?
The level? Sure, a JD isn't the same thing as a PhD, but it explicitly is at exactly the same level -- they're both doctoral degrees. The letters stand for Juris Doctor ("doctor of law") and Philosophiae Doctor ("doctor of philosophy").
As far as I can tell, The only place where a JD can teach in most universities is in the law school.
I don't understand what you're trying to say here. Assuming JD was universally acknowledged as a higher degree than PhD, this would still be true -- it's a subject matter restriction. if you have a PhD in history, you're probably stuck teaching in a history department -- it will not qualify you to teach in the math department, or in the law school.
As far as I know this is normal across the US - I don't know of any community colleges anywhere that ask for PhDs (since community colleges focus on teaching, not research)
Maybe the main take-away was a quote hidden toward the end related to listening to people with differing opinions:
> People don’t change their minds, they just change their opinion about the other side
It's hard to find the right pull-quote for it, but I thought the paragraphs about Libertarians being ignored are true: "I can’t help but think that efforts to unpack what separates red states from blue states haven’t been careful to differentiate between conservatives and libertarians. Venn diagrams of voters generally categorize voters as Republicans and Democrats or liberals and conservatives. But as is becoming increasingly apparent, the cool-headed libertarian in my classroom who’s willing to sacrifice his mother for the greater good doesn’t fit neatly into any of these circles."
I thought the comment about the framing of the gun control argument was good: "Imagine a gun control debate that avoided an argument over the value and necessity of guns, but instead was framed around how to protect civil liberties and limit gun violence without excessive governmental involvement. Imagine if care were taken to frame the discussion not as outsiders trying to impose their will on people whose culture they did not understand, but rather as one among people with a shared interest in protecting the safety of their children. My suspicion is a conversation like that would reveal useful common ground."
And I thought the comment on the abortion debate was apt: "I’ve also come to believe that if liberals started from the premise that the pro-life position is a legitimate argument that comes from love not hate, the tenor of the conversation about choice would be quite different. For if one were inclined to search for consensus rather than difference—to listen with curiosity rather than judgment—it’s possible to see far broader agreement on abortion in America than is commonly allowed."
To the extent that there is a conclusion, I think it's an argument that philosophy (and a liberal arts education) can be a useful in promoting understanding and resolving conflict: "We teach people that it’s impolite to discuss religion and politics in public. It’s wrong. We need to teach people how to discuss religion and politics. ... Instead of concerning ourselves with ensuring safe spaces for students, we need to create more spaces in which constructive conflict can occur. Trust me, no one will get hurt. Even in a classroom with divergent points of view on hot-button political issues, no one at App said anything racist or bullying. ... We can teach people to distinguish unreasonable arguments from reasonable arguments with which they disagree and, where differences are unresolvable, how to disagree reasonably."
This is incredibly naive, and misunderstands what a safe space is and what it is for. Many humans suffer from, for example:
* PTSD from abuse, war, or other trauma
* Neuroatypical behaviors that are mocked/belittled/ignored in the wider public (e.g. Crowd anxiety, tics, nervous behaviors, misreading social cues, etc.)
* Being Queer in an environment that is actively hostile
* Being a minority in some other capacity (racial, gender, cultural, ableness, economic, political, etc.)
Just existing in society can be high pressure and stressful -- a level of background noise in your daily life that most people don't see or recognize. A safe space is a place where you can let your guard down a bit, where you can simply be who you are without being challenged about it constantly.
I genuinely believe that having these spaces is a healthy thing for everyone who is in a stressful minority position. It doesn't matter if you are a trans kid at some university or a conservative tech worker in silicon valley -- having a place where you can feel comfortable and not judged for who you are is valuable. It does no one any good if we're all operating at maximum stress all the time.
> Trust me, no one will get hurt.
Unfortunately, as a queer person myself, I don't believe you. Polite conversation is a nice ideal, but things can escalate quickly if two people have fundamental disagreements. Despite the adage about sticks and stones, words can hurt people and lead to outcomes like self harm and suicide, removal from a community, etc.
I totally get that there needs to be places where people can go to avoid conflict, but that can't be everywhere. Conflict and debate are important parts of life.
If something is not effective, the only reason to do it is ideology and politics. Nobody needs even more of those on campuses.
Perhaps a better way to phrase the argument in favor to discussing divisive topics is that it helps us develop empathy for people who don't share our viewpoints.
It's not that we need to constantly berate people with them. It's not even that the conversations need to happen writ large in public (majority always wins in that case). However, it is vital that to try to understand where people are coming from. A good way to do that is by discussing things like religion and politics in small groups. It's good to have an honest conversation about divisive topics with someone who disagrees with them. It's bad to have a one-sided shouting match or even to have the case where it's 10-1 in a polite conversation and the 1 never speaks.
I think college is a good place to have these discussions. I feel like I gained a lot from the types of classes and discussions this article describes even at a time when I was extremely emotionally fragile and trying to recover from things I didn't fully understand yet. A places where people feel like they can "just be" is utterly critical. However, if we can't _also_ create some environments where people can talk honestly and learn to empathize with people who see things differently we risk losing out on a more welcoming and understanding society.
The districts are gerrymandered to hell, most college towns anywhere are pretty liberal, and many if not most colleges were founded by terrible people.
If you want to actually bridge a meaningful divide of any kind, you're better off talking to native rural citizens that aren't getting liberal arts degrees.
My experience with this country: the south tries to do better. The non-south-eastern US has never checked itself and just assumes the south is worse on all social norms and subjects.
> “A trolley is barreling down the tracks to which five people have been tied,” I explain during our second meeting. “You can flip a switch and divert the trolley, but you’d kill someone else who’s been tied to the sidetrack.”
I ask a young woman named Kierstin Davis what she would do. (It’s her real name—all of the students quoted here consented to participate in this article.) “I probably would flip the switch because I know less people would be killed,” she says. Almost all of her fellow students concur, albeit reluctantly. The notable exception is Jackson.
“You kill the one person,” he says without hesitation.
I don't understand — aren't the students all saying the same thing? Kierstin would flip the switch (which means divert the trolley and kill the one person), and Jackson would kill the one person. Am I missing something?
Fewer.
Difference in perspective? Maybe nothing?
If you answer "I flip the switch" - in order to be assured I have understood you correctly and that you understood the question correctly, I have to follow up with something like "So you'd kill the one?".
Saying "I kill the one" shortcuts some clarification and gives your answer directly and without ambiguity. Of course, if you're just a good communicator, you could give this clear answer without having experienced the question before.
But this article, and others like it, make me cringe like nothing else. A well-off academic type from the north reads "Hillbilly Elegy", decides to take a temp job / vacation in Boone and then writes about how much he learned about "America's divide" from a bunch of 18 year olds at a school for teachers and liberal arts students. Spare me please.
It's a tired trope. A well-heeled, educated outsider who comes down to teach the poor, ignorant working-class mountain folks the ways of civilization , but leaves having learned something heartwarming that money just doesn't buy.
Dudes like this need to stop using Appalachians as pawns for their narratives. The discussions he outlined could have happened anywhere. He just wants to get social credit for trying to "reach out", when all he really did was take a working vacation.
Meanwhile, you were hoping for a better article written from a more original perspective, and were disappointed. Maybe the writer of that article is out there somewhere, but how do we find them?
My point is that there is a whole genre of content that uses "Appalachia" and "Appalachians" as a stand in for the lower class other America. It's the one underprivileged group that white liberals can safely stereotype and exoticize without fear of repurcussions. And it's always outsiders with a pre-determined narrative who get to decide what Appalachia is like in the minds of non-appalachians, through books, movies, articles like this.
My point is more for anyone who thinks spending a few months in Appalachia gives them something worth writing about. It doesn't.
Well said.
But implicit in your statement is that some people (Appalachians/visiting lawyers) are bigoted and maybe someone took offence at that, or from your seeming too much "can't we all just get along?".
Really you can't take individual downvotes as anything except cosmic background radiation emitted from twitter and people having a bad day. People become annoyed (enraged even) because they hit 0 and go grey. With the steady increase in HN commenters, the raw post should start at 3 at least, or votes should be rationals (3 up/4 down) and only start to impact at n=3.