1. They're AMAZING.
2. They're not superhuman.
3. Major archival projects take time to prepare, set up, and execute.
4. Only public content is even potentially accessible. Much can get lost.
AT did a stellar job with G+, it's still a far cry from the access that was provided when Google hosted the content.
Google actively and by all appearances deliberately thwarted and frustrated archival efforts. This was a tremendous disappointment. It's quite likely Yahoo will do similarly.
If you want your own control over archives, you're going to want to use / run tools directly yourself.
TL;DR: AT is a huge benefit, but it's not a total solution.
Shouldn't the TL;DR: message be at the top of the comment, thereby not having to read the entire comment (since its too long :-)) to get the summary statement