> I do not believe that the five eyes have the ability to break modern encryption.
Do not be so sure. The Snowden documentation shows that they have many tools, from actual private attacks on the encryption itself to attacks on the endpoints (e.g. undocumented zero-day exploits) that can get data pre-encryption and/or post-encryption. And they don't limit themselves to endpoints in their own countries (that would be foolish for any intelligence agency to do).
If private industry is on the cusp of quantum computing, then to me it’s a safe bet that intelligence agencies have had it for years.
However, an advantage like this disappears the moment that evidence of its existence surfaces. It wouldn’t be used except in existential scenarios for that country.
It seems reasonable that incremental developments might have been made sooner by government than academic researchers or industry. Indeed, there are examples. But leaps like quantum computing?
I’m not ascribing this to you but I’ve noticed that there’s often a crossover between people who, on the one hand, believe government is pretty much incapable while, on the other hand, having some near magic ability to make huge technical leaps.
Wartime is different, as then it’s pretty much all hands on deck.
Private industries, which can only approach moonshots tepidly out of fiduciary responsibility, are already making good progress on this. My hunch is merely based on the liklihood that the DoD - which spends unfathomable amounts on R&D and does not answer to shareholders - has been going at this longer and much stronger than any private organization.
I'm not so sure; indeed there are examples of that (consider NSA setting the s-box parameters to make DES more secure) but at the same time there are so many "experiments" under way just I the course of everyday business (that happen to apply to dual use tech) that the military often finds itself a generation or so behind COTS / consumer tech.
> However, an advantage like this disappears the moment that evidence of its existence surfaces. [Thus] It wouldn’t be used except in existential scenarios for that country.
We've become more sophisticated since operation mincemeat (http://www.themanwhoneverwas.com). Such tech can be used for parallel construction: I discover via magic snooping that odyssey7 is planning something I don't like, and is doing it with odyssey6 who has poor security. I snoop on odyssey6 and build my case from that. Or I also learn that odyssey7 smokes pot, so break their car's tail light, have a cop stop them, search car, and magically find evidence used to build the real charge. Or whatever. The real breakthrough is hidden.
As far as I'm aware, there is no evidence at all that the commonly recommend encryption algorithms have any serious vulnerabilities when used properly. Now, it's easy to say that researchers would be given gag orders if they found the "magic back door", but that's all just speculation and fear-mongering really.
Additionally, it would be in the US's best interest for there to be no backdoor. Any vulnerability in RSA for example could be exploited against them.