Apple's Newest Store and the Perverse Logic of Philanthro-Capitalism
bostonreview.net
bostonreview.net
I dunno, this seems perfectly appropriate to me. Carnegie was all about whitewashing his monopolistic business practices with philanthropy. Now Apple can carry on his legacy!
This is a bit of an overlooked tidbit that I haven't seen "discussed" before much, or even articulated before.
Tech industry people for the most part really do genuinely believe that the things they build and profit from are inherently forces for good, that they "improve" the world in some way, usually however is defined by marketing. Even when the reality is in stark contrast.
Are the things we make really improving the world like we think they are?
Do things like Facebook and Twitter truly enrich our lives, or do they prey on our psychological need for community and attention in order to sell our "data" to advertisers.
Does a new $SMARTPHONE or $COMPUTER make the world "better" every year? Or does it simply compel people to buy the "new shiny" as the "old" is pushed out to pollute landfills and poison 3rd world countries.
Being in tech we live in an extremely isolated bubble. Quite literally, for most of us. We live in "tech hub" alcoves like Silicon Valley or Seattle with our climate controlled, Wi-Fi enabled existence. We work in ivory towers for wages that many would only dream of, with comforts that even the richest could only dream of a hundred years ago.
Of course even though it's a bubble, we can still see outside it. So we naively project the world we want out around it, our values and assumptions on how to fix it. We "make the world a better place" by shipping millions of "$100 laptops" to 3rd world countries. We have billionaires pledge to fix crises like Flint's drinking water. We have our companies act as extensions of ourselves with LGBT representation in "pride month"
Between the private sector and the government, the private sector is much more on the side of the angels these days when it comes to advocating for racial and religious minorities as well as the LGBTQ community than the government.
By nature of both the electoral college, gerrymandering, and each state no matter what its population having two Senators, the government doesn’t represent the will of the people in the US.
Business has one motivating principle - profit. I can deal with that much better than politicians who while they are motivated by money also and PACs, they also get re-elected by pandering to people with a belief system that isn’t in the best interests of anyone who does not fit with their definition of a “model American”.
I'm willing to bet most people on Hacker News don't live in Silicon Valley, we don't work for a FAANG, don't earn six figure salaries. But maybe you do.
Or does it simply compel people to buy the "new shiny" as the "old" is pushed out to pollute landfills and poison 3rd world countries.
Hasn't the complaint amongst analysts been that people are keeping their phones longer. Isn't this what is driving Apple's push towards services. I don't see environmental groups publishing charts showing phone use is driving climate change instead of travel or agriculture.
Given a choice between the antics of the tech industry vs those of the oil industry I'll take tech any day even if some of the are arseholes like Zuckerberg.