The Pixel 4 removed the fingerprint sensor, relying on the face recognition. I imagine that what happened is that the full functionality wasn't ready for launch, and they had to decide between shipping a partial implementation or postponing the phone's launch date.
1) Delay - yet another year where the pixel doesn't have good facial recognition. During this period all of the OEMs will probably implement some crappy FaceID knock off which will damage Androids image.
2) Bank on in-development facial recognition - Google has lots of talent, they can probably get it done. Risk, they don't get it done.
3) Include both - hardware costs go up, internal size goes up, and people will expect both the next year.
4) Skip facial recognition entirely - Get "left behind". AFAICT people expect facial recognition for unknown reasons. Further, there are several applications of facial scanning that enable non-biometric-security features (anti-features?).
Its easy to see how they chose option two. Sucks it didn't work out.
I don't know how Google weighed it or how they chose their priorities so I can't say whether or not they made the right call at the time (hindsight is 20/20). But based on your list, option 3 is the obvious choice to me.
There's also the question of how long they had from the hardware cutoff date to the software cutoff date - I'd guess many months. Why not allocate more resources to help with the facial recognition software? That project by itself for a company at Google's scale should not take that long. Like I said, this is no longer cutting-edge tech.
I guess we have to agree to disagree, but I think Google really fucked up the Pixel 4 and I bet it was a Product Manager who is responsible.
I worked in consumer electronics before. Your release date is set in stone as you have millions or even billions of € tied in marketing, ads and promotion prepared months in advance to go live on that one date.
You already booked air time on TV and rented billboards worldwide months in advance, you can't delay it on a short notice as airtime would be fully booked and you can't have ads for a product the consumers can't immediately buy.
That's why I left this industry.
Everything was run by marketing people who had no idea of engineering resources and would just promise clients everything to get the sale done and once the ink was dry on the sales contract they'd get a bonus and we'd get the overtime hours to try to implement whatever magical features they promised.
it’s not just electronics, consumer software is like this too…