[0] https://www.reddit.com/r/juststart/comments/dkyq92/how_i_was...
[0] https://www.reddit.com/r/juststart/comments/dkyq92/how_i_was...
This is the worst possible interpretation of OP's venture, and must be written by a 12 year old if $1900 is "stupid money"
Edit: I'm not saying that $1900 is not a significant amount of money to many people in the world. But it is NOT a lot of money in the context of developing/marketing a tech product in the first world.
> If OP had done any research, he would have realised "Russian Reddit clone" was not a good idea with a real likelihood of success. Way too ambitious.
> If OP had planned, he wouldn't have stumbled around aimlessly for 10 weeks and would have understood success, especially when growing any type of "community" based project, takes time.
I've now pasted 60% of the comment, and none of it is useful or actionable and is all rather insulting..."stumbled around aimlessly", "not a good idea", "throwing shit at a wall", these are trash statements and no budding entrepreneur should listen to them.
I'll also add that OPs approach is a typical "move fast and break things" method of finding a product-market fit, and it seems to me that OP did stumble upon a product and a market in a discussion platform for cancer patients. They need a monetisation strategy, but for somebody to turn around and say this is "shit" and was "aimless" is useless and shouldn't be encouraged.
How long might it take for a self-sustaining community to emerge? Surely longer than 6 weeks unless you pour a massive amount of money into ads or other pump-primers.
To be honest, the approach did resonate as fairly “aimless” to me. You may have a different opinion and that’s also ok.
Edit to add: “throwing shit against a wall and seeing what sticks” is an idiom of sorts. It does not mean that the literal thing being tried is being called “shit”.
Well, many people cannot get their hands on $2k readily to just burn away. I mean there are many articles like [0] and that is only the US, this is ofcourse far far worse in poorer countries so for a lot (majority?) of people in this world $2k is in fact "stupid money". And these people are not 12.
[0] https://money.cnn.com/2018/01/18/pf/lack-of-savings-cover-un...
I'd say most people "choose not to" save $1k than "cannot". I saved up a reasonable amount of money on $14/hr in Boston after graduation by living with roommates, not having a car, living frugally, etc. And conversely, I know plenty of people (developers even, who make lots of money!) who don't have that much saved.
I agree with you having savings or not might not be relevant of how much $1900 is, but that article was only one example and to me it seems relevant because if you don't have it in savings, how would you risk quitting your job? The tone of the reddit post shows that this person considers this actually to be a lot of money and from what I see I would say most people on earth would consider it a lot of money. The fact that you or I don't consider it to be a lot is kind of the echo chamber of HN we are in.
"There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, than are dreamt of in your philosophy."
$1900 is "stupid money" (as in hella expensive) for 1/3rd of the world's population. For some, it's more than they make in a year -- and yes, those places still have digital entrepreneurs.
And even in more economically advanced countries, $1900 can still be a lot for many demographics, even in the US, for e.g. a student or someone barely making the rent.
In 2018, the minimum wage in Russia was 11163 rubles per month, which is $174.6 per month. So, it would take a person working for a minimum wage 10.8 months to earn $1900.
For comparison, the minimum wage in California is $11/hour, so assuming a 40 hour work week, in 10.8 months a minimum wage worker in California would make $19,008. I'd guess that you would consider $19k to be a significant amount of money to spend on a project like this?
My point is, while you are right that $1900 is not "stupid money", it might still be a significant amount of money if the OP lives in Russia.
In fact, I'd think that a lot of people living in the United States would think that $1900 is a significant amount of money, especially for a risky side project.
It's even more dramatic than that however. The person earning minimum wage in Russia will never possess $1,900 in loose capital to spend on such a venture, as they don't have enough buffer beyond expenses to accumulate it. At $174 per month, saving 20% of that, it would take five years, and during those five years something would inevitably happen to consume the savings base (stray emergency need or other life event).
It's one aspect of the brutality of being poor, whether in Russia or the US or wherever. You rarely have breathing room above basic life expenses to accumulate anything. Opportunity almost always has a financial cost associated with it, a get-through-the-door dollar cost (whether that's buying equipment, renting commercial space, or just affording the free time to do a thing).
For the majority of the world $1,900 is more savings in terms of liquid cash (eg in a bank account), than they will ever have at a given point during their lifetimes. It's exceptionally hard for the majority of people to put that together.