Hacker News Reader

Comment by gkfasdfasdf | Hacker News Reader

The negative reactions here claiming that everyone should use English are really disappointing, on hacker news of all places. Nobody is saying we need to rewrite the Linux kernel in Arabic. But a language such as this could be a great tool to introduce programming to people who would otherwise be turned away by the language barrier. What is important is not the keywords for, if else, etc but the concepts of logic and computing. The more humans that can grasp these concepts, the better for all of us. Also who knows what genius lies untapped. Perhaps the next Linus or Knuth will come the streets of Baghdad, as a result of having been introduced into programming by an effort such as this one.

View on HN

English unite. Finally, after failed attempts with Esperanto and others, lots of educated people understand this single common language. Life is much easier. I am Czech and there are so little info in Czech on any technical subject so I rather search info straight in English. What I hate about Europe are these language barriers. There are so many countries with different languages, it is annoying that one is expected to talk differently after driving just 100 km. German, Polish, Slovak, Italian, Spanish, ...argh. This single language is a big advantage of USA! They will understand you in Miami, as they will in North Dakota or California. Very cool!

I totally agree. Let me say this. Europe has had at least three chances for a united language. 1) Latin when Caesar conquered europe. Italy, France, Spain, Portugal, Romania, adopted that language but later diverged, 2) frensh when Napoleon conquered europe and 3) german when Hitler conquered europe. I hope the EU will implement english a an official language even if the only english country (UK) will leave.

I agree with you. But I would phrase it differently: "A common language unites". We should not forget that at different times in different areas we had and to some extent still have different common languages (Greek, Latin, French, Arabic, Spanish). It seems that humans have such a strong desire to communicate across borders (cultural, inherited, political, etc.) that they will invent the necessary tools. English language is such a tool now. I wouldn't be surprised if in future it will be some other language. In the end, there will maybe one such common language accepted by all.

Thank you. Exactly.

A world of seven billion people, many opportunities for genius.

I have been surprised that non-English programming languages have not become even more common.

In my father's time, a university student of engineering or chemistry was strongly encouraged to learn basic German, in order to keep up with the state of art as published in leading professional journals.

Maths students would still do well to learn to read Russian.

English need not be forever.

I'm wondering how many people would be outright afraid of installing and running a program in a language that they have no chance of reading. This is the rough equivalent that all non-programmers have to deal with everyday.

At least not those people who install proprietary software on their systems.

Also, non-ASCII or non-Latin is just a step on a continuum: obfuscated code, machine language, spaghetti code, non-documented code... Actually, it may be perfectly workable to run the Arabic code through Google Translate and understand the result.

I think any argument taken to an extreme loses rationality.

On one hand, if more people can understand programming, then we increase the pool of programmers, and that's great. On the other hand, if more people can understand each other's programming, that's also great.

At the end of the day, what matters is that we have the largest possible ecosystem that also allows developers to transcend their geographical / ethnic background.

...and if that's the goal, then maybe it makes most sense for us to favor a unified ascii char set? A few language keywords aren't that big of a price for us all to stay on the same page.

It's possible but all the tools, the author of the language notes, have a 50 year head start in English with English language assumptions baked in, e.g. reading left to right vs right to left. What Qlb shows me is how hardcoded ASCII is in hardware and software.

I agree,that being said I think everyone agrees languages with good internationalization support (as in built to support translation of source code to a different language without affecting the logic and machine/byte code generated). Power to anyone making a language in their native tongue. I wonder if dying languages can be kept alive longer this way.

For a long-term perspective, all world should converge on one medium of exchange and everyone must learn that. I'm not suggesting an English hegemony here. We need to avoid balkanization.

Arabic language has subsumed many local languages to be dominant in that part of world. A Bedouin feels a cultural bias towards Arabia if he starts coding in this language.

I'm from India and non-Hindi speaker; if coding is done in Hindi it's cultural bias towards Northern India as opposed to where I'm from.

Is there a programming language that uses Esperanto?

No, but programming languages exist in English, which is used by more than 15 people.

Esperanto is a very interesting language but it will never be more than a plaything, a linguistic experiment, or a framework for people to learn a language that actually gets spoken by people.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com