How you know an academic has never worked the ER.
How you know an academic has never worked the ER.
I don’t think even the most isolated docs would be naive enough to trust an incoming intoxicated patient about their own substance use.
So likely there is a happy medium between (1) being totally naive towards everyone who comes into the ER and (2) denying that ABS exists. i.e. Be aware of alternative explanations which may be rare but not non-existent.
If you are going to hold someone in the ER until their BAC is 0 it seems fairly cheap to give them sugar water and see if their BAC increases.
However, if you're waiting for an actual discharge from the ER, it's common to hold onto the patient until their BAC is under the legal limit, do another quick neuro exam, and then start discharge procedures.
The idea here is "the patient is almost certainly just drunk, but it's not impossible they have an underlying problem such as hepatic encephalopathy. So I'm going to wait for them to sober up enough that I can tell the difference between 'drunk' and 'underlying altered mental status' before I start discharge. The time it will take the discharge to go through will be enough to get their BAC to 0, and I will therefore not be liable if they walk out of the ER and fall and crack their head."
To me this implies they can hold you, as I can't just walk out whenever I want? Why? I feel no compulsion to be held so that they can minimize their liability.
Breathalyzers don't cost much at all, ER visits costs thousands of dollars. You can tell someone to go drink sugar water at home. Why would a doctor need to hold someone and give the sugar water?
That attitude, while somewhat justified, contributes to the stated underdiagnosis...