Here's the article on Star Control II by the same author (Jimmy Maher) as the OP:
https://www.filfre.net/2018/12/star-control-ii/
Although I love Maher's "Digital Antiquarian", I feel his opinion on SC2 is a tad unfair.
He basically criticizes the game for having a living, evolving game world where you can lose simply by taking too long. That's one of the things that originally blew my mind about SC2 back in 1992: it truly feels like a universe that's not artificially made for the player. You're just one ship trying to understand great forces that are in motion on their own, and will eventually crush you.