Now that I think about it, I wonder how well any of them keep time without syncing to their app.
You might be surprised: https://www.cnbc.com/2016/05/23/study-shows-fitbit-trackers-...
I check my pulse against a stopwatch during the same minute that Chinese no-name is counting my pulse, and the result is the same.
There's your answer right there. If people keep buying then why would they charge less?
And this is enough to justify the device for me. It only cost $150 or so, lasts much longer than a year, and earns its keep in useful functionality.
This is one of those things where limiting the functionality of the device enhances the usability of it. I can easily do the 3 or 4 things I actually want a watch to do on my fitbit(stopwatch, heartrate, pedometer, see who's calling) and don't have to worry about dumb stuff like receiving phone calls or watching video on a tiny screen.
It eventually irritated my skin (I had burn marks right under the light) so I had to give it up. Even with regular cleaning, I could not stop the strap itching.
The nice thing about Garmin (the company) is that they gave me a full refund even though it was well past the 30-day return. I haven't gone back to do the research on avoiding the skin issues, but I hope some day I'll be able to buy a Garmin again.