We, the other scientists (just like the voters) incentivize certain behaviors and with that favor a certain type of scientists (and politician) to prosper.
There are all kinds of scientists (and politicians) competing for your trust (and votes). There are good and bad among them. As long as we reward the bullshitters more, they are the ones that will outcompete the others.
All these rules and regulations that people propose are ineffectual, as long as a certain level of self-criticism is not being applied:
- Stop believing and propagating the bullshit even if it seems to support your preconceived notions (or even the truth). This is very hard to do in practice.
As sad as it sounds: the greatest enemy of good science are the other scientists.
feels like some sort of prisoners's dilemma, it only works if all do it, otherwise, it is best to just not admit anything