LanceH said:
> there is a bit about her contribution which is over inflated
to which you said:
> Why do you diminish this woman contributions to mathematics?
LanceH didn't. He acknowledges her contributions elsewhere in the comment. He is saying that characterizing it as "reshaping mathematics" is likely an exaggeration. At the very least, the BBC article doesn't give an indication of how she did this, and doesn't back the stance. Even a great contribution to the theory of plasticity is not one that reshapes mathematics. It's an extraordinary claim. While in academia, I worked with people who made incredible contributions to a sub-sub discipline of physics. Within the sub-sub discipline they are recognized as the leaders/pioneers of the field. Yet they are unknown to most physicists, and no one (including they themselves) would dare make a claim that they "reshaped physics". Mathematics is a broader discipline and it takes even more to reshape it than it does physics.
LanceH said:
> to make a trite statement about equality of opportunity
To which you responded:
> Are you saying equal opportunity is trite?
LanceH wasn't. What was being said is that writing an article pointing out how few opportunities women had at the time is trite (definition: "boring from much use : not fresh or original"). If they want to write yet another article documenting this, that is fine. But they should title the article to reflect it.
A famous blind programmer once complained of the same phenomenon: That articles written about him focus more on his blindness than on his achievements. I don't know how Hilda would feel about this article, but I would not be happy if I made an achievement and all that is written about me is related to my gender/race/disability and not the work I've done.