I wonder if that means that it has failed to achieve its purpose. Libraries were created in an age where books were scarce and expensive. This isn’t really true anymore, except for science or art books. What has become rare are common social spaces where you are not expected to consume. Churches used to be that, but now they’re empty. What about „libraries“ that focus on the social part, not the storing-paper part? Quiet places to read for people who want to leave their apartment, maybe because they’re lonely. Book clubs with discussions to foster intellectual exchange. The equivalent of the coffee houses old, without the blaring pop music of todays chain stores.
Yes. The whole 3rd floor is open plan, so the noise from the kids play area and from the cafe carries over to the books area. And the magazines section is right next the kids play area, so there it's especially not quiet.
I have also read very interesting magazines while having coffee there.
Sure there will always be some people complaining. By most metrics, Oodi has been a massive success.
If you have some free time and are in the vicinity, it is a great destination.
Most tourists tend to instead stay in southern Helsinki which is fine but quite boring in my opinion.