Don't car dealerships do this all the time? Or small shops in Chinatown that negotiate for tourist souvenirs? Safeway or CVS cards? Google AdWords? Priceline.com? Employee/corporate discounts? Heck, on my recent trip to the Grand Canyon, my sister and I both checked out the exact same rental car through our respective employers, and it was about $30 cheaper through mine, presumably because my employer gives a better corporate discount than her employer. Really,
anything where you negotiate the price will end up with different prices for the same item.
You're thinking that just because people don't do it, it must be illegal. The idea of "one price for identical items" is a pretty recent invention, dating back to the rise of department stores (Woolworth's, Macy's, Sears) at the turn of the 20th century. It's for economic reasons, not legal ones. They found that it was cheaper to forego the extra revenue than it was to hire all the salespeople needed to negotiate each individual purchase. Charge less and make it up in volume. It also has the advantage of fairness and simplicity, which customers tend to like.