Hacker News Reader

Comment by notadoc | Hacker News Reader

Keep in mind the original post is an opinion piece with a political agenda, it is not evidence based.

There is no shortage of bad opinion pieces with all sorts of terrible politically driven opinions out there. This is one of them.

View on HN

I’ll give a short anecdote that might sway your opinion. I grew up poor in Baltimore City. I directly benefitted from the CTY program, where I was able to take accelerated math courses over the summer. My family didn’t pay a dime of the $3k+ per summer cost to attend. After several summers of CTY, I was able to take AP Calculus as a freshman in high school. I would not be who I am today without CTY.

I agree, that article written by the director of CTY is biased. And most who attended were rich kids, so maybe in aggregate their approach doesn’t make a difference. But it made a difference for me. CTY provided opportunities for me I never would have had otherwise.

I definitely noticed class differences in CTY my first time - there were kids who seemed like CTY was normal but for myself, I was blown away and felt like I was in another world. Eventually I realized these kids were also ones who traveled internationally a lot, or did science fair competitions regularly, played multiple musical instruments, were learning different languages like chinese and french, were legacy kids for ivy league parents, etc. Meanwhile I was the kid who was good at basketball and soccer during breaks because everyone else was a nerd.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com