Ironic that union membership would become just another form of heritable wealth.
Ironic that union membership would become just another form of heritable wealth.
We shouldn’t chop up the middle class’ heritable tokens while letting the upper class keep theirs.
That just makes things worse.
While one may gave an advantage to their off spring the previous effectively restricts others and is way unhealthier for society.
Just treating it like factions where just whose team is good for isn't a very healthy approach.
It's a great evil that needs to be stomped on viciously.
I’m pretty sure it doesn’t seems that way to most of the people, most of the time.
Maybe somehow you can get to a place where your influence on your fate seems more real?
(At least that would imply a pretty nice improvement in labor conditions - no more workers being flattened by containers! Which is also the kind of thing unions typically care about.)
It should be the case no doubt, but often isn’t because there’s less to leverage. Sometimes you need a favor, you know? But if you give a job to Joe Schmuckus that he could get anywhere, whats the motivation to do you a solid?
- Efficiency is implicitly good.
- Material rewards can/should be allocated according to some measure of individual merit and competence.
- Meritocracy and nepotism are distinct.
I tend to agree, but these statements are at least controversial (if not obviously wrong) within the political consciousness that does labor organizing these days. Read Jacobin sometime, you'll see vehement opposition. Internalizing the violent logic of capitalism, etc.
not saying jobs should be doled out that way, but it's quite different to get a chance at future income vs. having it mounded in your lap without lifting a finger.
So like a taxi medallion. Which when sold on a free market had (before Uber, in NYC) a market value on the order of a million dollars.
That's a pretty huge advantage to pass down.
If longshoremen were allowed to buy and sell their union memberships (say in the form of "union member medallions") they'd probably have similar value to taxi medallions.
The problem isn’t the economic system, the problem is human nature.