Is there something wrong with Intel management/culture that's allowing other firms to run rings around them?
Is there something wrong with Intel management/culture that's allowing other firms to run rings around them?
Could they have seen it coming? Absolutely, and they could have had a new architecture ready earlier or adjusted their process plans to de-risk, but again, multiple years of uncontested dominance in their main business tends to make things that aren't next quarter top-line a lower priority. And I think that really is at the heart of the issue with their projects failing so frequently. Intel's pursued anti-competitive practices for decades, and when it works, they coast along without urgency, letting marketing call the shots, and when it doesn't they use their economic moat to rush a solution.
But this time, with everything running late, Intel is going to face several quarters ahead without having a real response on the CPU front. They are not going anywhere, though. Their foundry channel is needed to meet global demand for new chips - a good deal will still find buyers. They still have plenty of existing agreements to work with, and can negotiate their way through a lean patch. And they have their new GPU stuff coming soon which should hopefully give them a piece of a different market. There will be plenty of stress to re-org along the way, though, so Intel could come out of this looking very different.
That's how competition works. You are constantly making decisions, each of which could bury you, even if you was a total winner only yesterday.
Intel put its bet on own fab and single die design. AMD outsourced the fab and focused on chiplet design. And AMD gain a benefit.
Though Intel still has some advantage, and would move to chiplet design soon most likely, so we would yet see a very tight competition.
https://semiaccurate.com/2018/06/29/intels-firing-of-ceo-bri...
This is what happens when an incumbent company delays new products because of mismanagement or to maximize profits. (See also, Apple)
A CPU isn't like a database, it's easy for customers to switch to a competitor.
Weren't AMD cpus a good alternative to intel for most consumers ? If I remember correctly athlon, phenom, FX were pretty good for the price. Or are you talking about earlier times ?
edit: "good alternative" perf/price wise, yes intel used to have the advantage in raw performance but their pricing made AMD cpus look very interesting for most consumers.
So between about 2010 and the introduction of Ryzen in 2017, there really was no alternative to Intel if you were building a PC that was either fast or energy efficient. In terms of performance, the 1000 & 2000 series Ryzens roughly attained parity with Intel, while the 3000 series now pulls ahead in many multithreaded and some singlethreaded disciplines, and definitely has better performance-per-watt under load.
Ryzen still draws significantly more power than Intel's CPUs when idle though - the PCIe 4.0 transition has counteracted the improvements from the 7nm shrink in this regard, and the APU variants lagging the GPU-less SKUs by almost a year in terms of process and microarchitecture means you also have to power budget for a discrete GPU, which adds a few idle watts.
(The most power efficient at idle Ryzen build I'm aware of is the Asrock DeskMini A300, which uses no chipset, combined with a low end APU - this draws about 7W when idle. In terms of performance and expandability, this system isn't any better than a NUC, which draws somewhat less power when idle. You can't buy a full size A300/X300 motherboard though, for some reason, even though this would actually be quite an interesting setup.)
https://www.newegg.com/Product/SingleProductReview?item=N82E...
The highly reputable c't Magazine used it in one of their recommended PC builds recently. They tend to be very thorough and fussy about issues, so I suspect they didn't run into whatever issue you're talking about. I believe they did mention that you need to watch out for BIOS support for the 3000 series CPUs (and ask the seller to update it if necessary and you don't have an older AM4 APU handy), as with any motherboards that predate release of a particular CPU you're trying to use.
Then Intel Core came out in 2006 and it was game over for AMD until Zen was introduced in 2017.
Between 2006 and 2016 AMD looked half-dead most of the time.
Projects fail. It's expected. The only way to have no failing projects is not to create experimental projects.
But AMD is definitely catching up and that's a good thing.