My real worry, and the real reason this shouldn't be done, is that it shouldn't be made so easy that some clever hackers can do it, or gets accidentally triggered for some reason. But ye olde "shoot the place up" can take down the internet pretty effectively. "Stray backhoes" have done a decent job a couple of times within my experience as it is; the hard part is keeping the net running, not shutting it down.
These sorts of things are important because ease dictates more of what happens in life than posibility. Make it easier to turn off the net, there is more chance of it happening, and it'll take less resources from the controlling party to do it.
Like you said, 'they' could already turn off the internet. So why bother with the effort to make a killswitch? Because the resources it'd take to kill the internet manually matter.
~~~~~~~
An similar argument might be, "If someone can always find a flaw in crypto implementations, why bother with cryptography?" or "You can walk anywhere a car can go, what's the point of having a car?"
Because the resources it'd take to kill the internet manually matter
They only need to turn off one big ISP or 2 before the others are going to shut down themselves. Look at what happened with Wikileaks. If someone can always find a flaw in crypto implementations,
why bother with cryptography?
That's a pretty big IF, because it depends on finding flaws, and there is no recipe for that and you're also not certain if you're going to find any, regardless of the time/resources invested.Also, crypto algorithms are public, peer reviewed and usually you're going to find out if a flaw exists sooner or later. And because there isn't any available method to make brute force attacks any easier or feasible if the key is large.
I am pretty sure the government can shut down the Internet, but I can bet they aren't able to decrypt my communications if I won't allow it ;-)
'They' could already turn off the internet. So why bother with the effort to make a killswitch? Because the resources it'd take to kill the internet manually matter.
I think of that in terms of 1) simple manpower, 2) cooperation, and 3) perception.
EDIT: removed Emergency Broadcast System analogy.
Also, an 'internet switch' could selectively filter, it could allow the communication of one faction but not the other.
If it weren't for that North Korea and Myanmar wouldn't last for 5 minutes under their present leadership, the same goes for many other countries.
Anyway, that doesn't change my point, having control infrastructure already in place does make it a lot easier for them.
Very easy to understand: they don't have lots of men with guns the moment they ask these men to point to their family members, to their community, in a wrong way . People will not obey things that go against the law, because they are not drones, and oppose firmly unless the law itself makes them comply(no exit).
If you have the force but not the authority law gives you, your force is briefly temporal.
E.g It was essential for Hitler to get a law that gave it full powers, using the excuse of punishing the communist for Reichstag fire, fire that could had been caused by Nazi supporters.
Unfortunately this is the most recent of a pretty long series, so it probably would't be much fun to read unless you had read the series up to this point. But if anyone wants an interesting fictional scenario where the 'Net is knocked entirely (or almost entirely) offline, there ya go...