Supreme Court Allows Sandy Hook Families' Case Against Remington Arms to Proceed
npr.org
npr.org
This case is about the advertising that the manufacturer did.
Also, the case is just being allowed to proceed, it hasn't been decided yet. It may well be that there is a desire to make a steadfast ruling on the subject overall, hence allowing the procedure.
For what it's worth, I think the case itself is weak.
But yes, if a liquor advertises to minors, or even advocates for drunk driving in ads, then I would expect them to be sued. And yes, if auto manufacturers advertise in a way that leads to an increase in impaired driving, I would expect them to be liable for their advertising as well.
Do we want to effectively ban advertising a product as fit for a legal purpose, if that purpose has some functional overlap with illegal ones? It’s a reasonable question. How such a law would be implemented and executed, however, worries me greatly.
It is one thing if e-cig manufacturers get sued for marketing as smoking cessation devices while talking about flavor or advertising on influencers - it is damn clear that they are dodging anti-tobbaco advertisement and advertising nicotine to minors and the standard of evidence is well established. But trying to draw connection between the machismo and spree shooters? It seems far too speculative when courtroom junk science based on the desired outcome has already caused problems.
Plus how easily used for the next moral panic. For a silly example that Minecraft causes illegal and unpermitted construction when it is really say priced out younger generations building their own squats.
Also, the counter argument might be: are movie studios, music labels, video game manufacturers, etc. liable also because they glorify gun violence as a business model? That would be a far reaching consequence. Car ads show people driving cars pretty aggressively; would they now be liable for when people get in accidents due to driving aggressively?
>the Sandy Hook families say Remington "published promotional materials that promised 'military-proven performance' for a 'mission-adaptable' shooter in need of the 'ultimate combat weapons system.' " They also accuse the company of fostering a "lone gunman" narrative as it promoted the Bushmaster, citing an ad that proclaimed, "Forces of opposition, bow down. You are single-handedly outnumbered."
A militia is an organization, not an individual. Well-regulated organizations have a stated and understood mission, rules as to how that mission will and will not be pursued, and governance that is independent of the execution of that mission.
Thus we have civilian oversight of the military, legislative oversight of the executive as part of checks and balances, boards of directors overseeing corporations and non-profits, etc.
A solitary individual with a gun, no matter how good a person they are, is neither well-regulated nor a militia.
Now, leaving the firearms debate and politics out of it, if the same principles applied to every other industry the alcohol, tobacco, and automotive industries would all be out of business. At some point, society is going to have to realize that we should be protecting our children by at least the same standards that we use to protect our money.
Remington sells a lot of guns, but this particular model was advertised with phrases like "ultimate combat weapons system" and "Forces of opposition, bow down. You are single-handedly outnumbered," and emphasized its standard 30-round magazine where Remington's own hunting and competition rifles have 5- or 10-round mags.
They were specifically advertising this particular gun as a great way to kill a lot of people.
So there's a pretty clear rationale for the focus of the ad - including the emphasis on magazine capacity. That said, competition guns all use standard capacity magazines except in the very few jurisdictions where they are forced to use diminished capacity magazines. My local sporting goods store doesn't even have magazines that are less than 30 rounds.
This is typically the case because of hunting laws that require them. In many states, hunting with a standard magazine is the norm. For an AR, that’s 20 or 30 rounds.
> They were specifically advertising this particular gun as a great way to kill a lot of people.
... which, in some circumstances, is perfectly legal by the way. To illustrate that, here’s an ad from the 1930s for a submachinegun that ran in magazines to market to the general public: https://farm1.staticflickr.com/23/35177769_79a70efcb0.jpg
Marketing is a powerful, proven effective force often with large financial backing, and it's possible that it doesn't always have the end consumer's interests at heart.
Based on that it seems reasonable to allow cases like this to be heard, to determine whether the manufacturer could have been more careful to prevent harm, or whether they mislead consumers.
I'd personally be more scared of a world in which there was no prospect for the public to hold court hearings about the content of potentially damaging and/or misleading advertising.
Brings forth the whole marketing attribution problem - wonder if there is any jurisprudence around this