Yes I found this very amusing. For several reasons:
- Within a week he seems to have found that the content of the book was more effective than years of his treatment of atleast one patient
- He buries this as deeply within the article as possible
- This experience casts light on the crux of my issue with the article, which is that it is very much a "prereplication" book review.
The reality is that neither the author of the book or the review have solid empirical evidence one way or the other, in terms of modern style studies. The book review seems to be drawing an overly negative conclusion about the research because of this fact. To me this is a demonstration of an overreliance on empiricism that seems to dog alot of western medicine practitioners in general.
I found this line very revealing:
>later studies – done in an atmosphere of boredom, by large multi-center consortia – are almost always disappointing.
I'm not sure what the phrase "atmosphere of boredom" signifies but it doesn't sound like a faithful attempt to get something to work. If you are doing any of these treatments in an atmosphere of boredom will it actually be effective? Is doing it in an atmosphere of boredom really a valid way of testing it?
I haven't read the book but will read it. It does seem to me that the thesis of the book, that trauma causes the mind to disconnect from the body and shapes the body, is something that Chinese medicine / Qi Gong practitioners have known about for thousands of years. I don't have any empirical evidence to back these specific practices but I have mountains of anecdotal evidence that would seemingly be rejected by the author of the review.