Perhaps you think there are certain feedback loops that need to be broken (your model is usually a static representation of the reality), or perhaps you prefer low rate of false negatives / false positives, or perhaps if a model is uncertain you would like to defer to a human.
If a model predicts high probability of re-offence, you might decide to delay an action as an example, or re-examine the case in more detail.
I get a feeling that machine learning practitioners are not properly trained to recognize such subtleties, everything is a binary softmax output these days :)
EDIT: This seems to stem from the obsession with purely discriminative models that either directly model a binary function y = f(x) or model a function that returns some kind of score, which is later compared to a threshold y = f(x) > theta. Neither of these lend themselves nicely to this conceptual separation between modeling and decision making.