I'm able to understand other physics concepts like relativity, but quantum mechanics seems too entrenched in mathematics at this point in time. I have a very hard time visualizing what is going on.
I'm able to understand other physics concepts like relativity, but quantum mechanics seems too entrenched in mathematics at this point in time. I have a very hard time visualizing what is going on.
Quantum mechanics is not very amenable to learning by analogy. Especially in an example like this where you're following the evolution of a state vector back and forth and the trick is in how that state is manipulated. In some ways that's a plus. You can't oversimplify important details away. I personally thought this was one of the best pieces for teaching a QC subject that I've ever read. It's clear, it flows, and it's as simple as possible and no simpler.
They're natural consequences of the formalization being described and are explained as physical or visual consequences of moving different elements of the diagram around. This is pretty fascinating because the analysis feels informal given how fluent and visual it is, but it can be completely formalized through a logic of graph transformations which let you translate these graphs into algebraic equations.
I haven't finished the book yet, but building from this formalism they begin to demonstrate how this formalism appropriately describes Hilbert spaces (it's an abstract theory to the more concrete model of Hilbert spaces) which then get us very close to standard Quantum formalisms. You can already begin discussing qubits, various standard quantum bases, and basic computational reasoning based on these systems.
It's a really excellent!
I don't know if I was just grumpy from the struggles of trying to parse this, but having the author interrupt every other paragraph with a tangent about how I shouldn't feel bad for not understanding this immediately didn't particularly help matters.
Can you expound on this thought a bit? It's not entirely obvious to my why using math, or mathematical concepts, to explain something necessarily invalidates the explanation.
The only people who sort of grok QM are the ones who have 'artificially machine learned' it after years of working with it. Arguably that's also true of the people who grok classical physics.
http://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/the-talk-3?fbclid=IwAR3vAxI...