“Affordances,” a science-fiction story by Cory Doctorow
slate.com
slate.com
---
got an epub http://www.filedropper.com/affordances
My feeling is that DRM is just encryption for artists. If you think that encryption and privacy are good things that empower people, I don't know why you would want to disempower artists.
But he thinks differently.
If you're free from State coercion and can exercise of your natural rights, how can AI hurt you?
In the first story, what's really interesting but CD ignores, is the hows and whys of the apparent slavery. Instead of focusing on that, he deep-dives into the minutiae of the UI.
Who cares if it's AI-related or not? Would they be better off if they were forced to create Creative Commons-licensed content or assemble solar panels?
https://boingboing.net/2019/08/13/malice-vs-incompetence.htm...
From his article:
> The point isn't that it's inconceivable that Epstein died as the result of a conspiracy, but the conspiracy theories that say that it has to be a setup because it's so implausible that prison authorities would be so totally useless are thoroughly disconnected from reality.
That's a complete strawman of what people are saying. No one thinks it's inconceivable that the prison system is incompetent. They do think the highest profile prisoner on the planet with ties to the most powerful people on the planet killing himself in a prison that hasn't had a suicide in 21 years looks like a conspiracy. I agree.
That seems very much like siding with the establishment to me.
However, he seems a bit too bullshitty nowadays. While I agree with him on OSS/CreativeCommons/etc he seems to be arguing with no one as copyright maximalists have different points.
Also his recent Walkaway novel has a long couple of pages about meritocracy is a myth and a tool of the man and it’s all about random access, etc.
I believe his main point is this:
> The state of US prisons is a national shame, and the fact that America incarcerates more people than any other nation in world history in these gulags is a national horror.
As Ben Hunt puts it, you don't have to think any one oligarch is responsible to hold them all responsible: https://www.epsilontheory.com/im-a-superstitious-man/
https://www.foxnews.com/us/epstein-new-york-lockup-suicides
> Prior to Epstein, the only other reported suicide at MMC occurred 21 years ago, when Philadelphia mobster Louis Turra hanged himself with a bedsheet tied to the window bars of his cell.
> The last suicide at the Manhattan jail before Mr. Epstein’s was in 2006, according to the bureau.
He is completely correct here. I mean, just look up the definition of "conspiracy theory"[1] - It is literally what people claim (Epstein didn't kill himself, i.e. he was killed as a result of some secret or covered up plot).
You may be taking offence because "conspiracy theorist" has negative connotations (eg black helicopters, chemtrails, 9/11 inside job, jfk shooter, deep state, illuminati...). But there are conspiracy theories that pen out to be true in the long run - NSA surveillance revelations post-Snowden certainly fulfill many conspiracy theories of a decade ago.
All that said, I don't particularly care about Epstein. Your entire post just attacks the messenger for a single view you disagree with, rather than the content at hand. You don't have to agree with a person all the time or none of the time, there are options in between.
[1] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/conspiracy%20theo...
Just don't look too closely at the fact that he worked for the law firm which negotiated Epstein's original sweetheart deal, or that his ex-OSS father plucked Epstein out of obscurity to teach at the Dalton school in Manhattan and also wrote a book about extraterrestrial sex slavers ....
Look, it's fun to think about, but at the end of the day he had very rational reasons to kill himself. He was about to go to prison for the rest of his life and, given that it's the US prison system, could realistically expect to be violently murdered there by his fellow inmates.
He signed his last will and testament two days before his death, it's pretty solid evidence that he had an exit plan and was putting his affairs in order.
There’s nothing ordinary about his death (or life). There’s been a well documented cover up of his activities by the media and multiple governments going back at least a decade. None of that has been properly addressed.
Any negative connotation associated with people who question Epstein’s death isn’t addressing the main issue with his case: powerful people have successfully avoided being prosecuted for child sex trafficking. That’s the issue, not that people don’t believe what they’re being told about Epstein from those documented to be involved with him.
I don't blame people for being suspicious of his story at first glance, but really looking at the facts, it's most plausible that he believed he wouldn't get away with anything this time and took the easy way out. This is wholly independent of the problem of the wealthy and connected getting the kid glove treatment by the legal system.
Nearly every official and media outlet saying it was suicide is directly implicated in the scandal. Including Barr who’s father gave Epstein his first teaching job.
How are these media outlets directly implicated?
There should be no doubt that many people don't believe he committed suicide. He escaped punishment once, none of his co-conspirators have been punished, the media has been caught manipulating the story, many powerful people have been caught lying. Why should anyone think the corruption all the sudden stopped?
When people start getting punished, then maybe we can believe the people who held them accountable. Until then, all we've seen is corruption and deception and enough people have noticed that no amount of media manipulation will get people to believe that Epstein just happened to kill himself at the most convenient possible time for some of the most powerful people in the world, in an environment where that's only happened once in 40 years.
> When people start getting punished, then maybe we can believe the people who held them accountable.
The two guards who were clearly negligent have just been indicted by a federal grand jury this week, it's a start.
They assume literally everyone whose name they recognize is a secret pedophile without even a scintilia of unreliable evidencd in deranged guilt by association.
That they treat "wanting more conclusive evidence in speculative matters" as "siding against" only proves the point. It fits the "more about emotional validation and confirmation bias than investigation" mold to them.
Real title: "Affordances". Don't editorialize, please.
It tells me who the author is (which in this case is information I care about), and what the article is going to be about. In contrast, "Affordances" tells me literally nothing. At best, maybe I could assume that article will be about UX design?
I'm all for titles being neutral, but I also want to know whether or not something is worth clicking on. I'd be fine with a rename like, "Affordances: A sci-fi story by Cory Doctorow", but for my sake please don't just give the title of an article in isolation if that title provides no context.