Hacker News Reader

Comment by bitwize | Hacker News Reader

They might want to consider revising that decision because X is going away. If they don't, wmii will go away with it.

X has been going away for longer that the careers of most people on this site.

At this point maybe even longer than a substantial chunk has been alive.

Says who? X.org will be supported for at least the next 10 years as part of RHEL 8. Not to mention the possibility that someone other than Red Hat could continue supporting it after that time.

It'll be in "hard maintenance mode" meaning bug/security fixes only. Anything new and interesting in the graphics space will be Wayland only. I also believe they intend to deprecate and then remove Xwayland from the graphics stack, at least in releases newer than some flag day in the near future, as Xorg itself is only being maintained for the sake of legacy applications.

Ok, this is all true, but none of it is the same as "X is going away".

I can't help but think that this X deprecation talk from RH is just some chest beating to rally the troops behind Wayland, same as we used to hear from Ubuntu about Mir.

That's how you get people to use your stuff when they would otherwise dig in their heels because "what I have is fine", "muh Unix philosophy", etc. It worked for systemd.

"What I have is fine" is a perfectly valid reason not to go changing things, IMO.

Excuse me sir or madam. Firstly, X11 even in its heyday was often criticized as not being very Unix-philsophy-ish. But I don't think you make a very sophisticated argument when you mock criticism by imitating flawed speech.

I'll continue to use X because I don't find it very broken. That's a problem for you?

I do however have a problem when open source introduces dependencies on buggy software written by aggressive narcissists, so yeah, I'm in the anti-systemd camp, or, put myself there when it started hanging a bunch of my Debian machines at boot when they made the switch. Pulseaudio was similarly garbage.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com