The ‘Silicon Six’ spread propaganda. It’s time to regulate social media sites
washingtonpost.com
washingtonpost.com
That's not (at all) what he argues.
While I might not agree with his ideas, I also don't think boiling a complex issue down to hyperbolic, and misleading, sound-bytes like this one is any way helpful.
I realize that's a controversial idea for obvious reasons. But to dismiss it outright as finding "other people" who will "tell you how to think" is disingenuous.
I have seen that asserted but I haven't heard explicit answers. Why do you or others think it isn't tennable? How do you think it will collapse with lack of action?
They do damage to their own credibility with their incessant pushing on a flimsy and selective basis.
Propaganda is most often used to motivate state goals, such as war, with falsehoods. Government and government/industrial partnership is the main source of propaganda. Conspiracy theories are generally anti-propaganda in the sense that they contradict the official story.
Its true that there are many conspiracy theorists who are racist. However, its certainly not all of them. I would be considered a hardcore 'conspiracy theorist' by most but I'm not the least bit racist. I am a white man who dated asian women and lives in Mexico. I don't pretend to know anything about people who I don't know. Conspiracy theories are also extremely popular with black Americans.
The problem with large companies or the government "regulating propaganda" is that, as I mentioned, they are the biggest sources of propaganda. What you will end up with is something along the lines of Chinese government information control.
I do, however, believe that we should make an effort to reduce the propagation of racism, and extreme views that are deliberately false. But whatever form this takes, it must not be monopolized by one organization or establishment, and must be structured in the context that I described, rather than a false context where anti-establishment views are automatically censored. One possibility might be to use the legal system. For example, some legal action could disqualify political candidates who blatantly lie about their opponents. Of course, this is extremely challenging, since that would disqualify all candidates in the current system.
"What are they trying to hide by controlling what we say and censoring our attempts to expose the truth?"
I liked this expression because people regularly conflate the right to speak freely with the supposed right to have their speech amplified and distributed (at zero cost), which isn't a thing. I made no mention whatsoever about what speech is, or isn't, acceptable.
> "the supposed RIGHT to have their speech amplified and distributed ... isn't a thing"
No such RIGHT exists, period. End of sentence. That right isn't "a thing".
I've never made a comment supporting "de-platforming", or anything of the sort, so I'm not sure where that came from. All I did, was point out the confusion people have regarding their actual rights. Somewhat ironically, your response perfectly illustrates my point. So, thank you.