If the Series A rounds were 1 on 3 ($1M on $3M pre-money valuation), then $150k would get him 3.75%. For hotter startups, 1 on 4 or 5 might actually happen. Presumably they would have the option to put more in, but that would increase their basis.
But your assessment is right. Average time to liquidity for a VC backed startup is 7+ years-- older than the oldest YC company, right? There is a TON of value locked in in previous YC companies.