Is there anything beyond the semantics of the Google statement that makes you feel that it's false?
Is there anything beyond the semantics of the Google statement that makes you feel that it's false?
To be clear, I believe that everything Google has actually stated is factual. You're just drawing wrong conclusions from partial information. So in one sense, no, because Google hasn't lied. I don't have any proof that I could share. But yes, I have strong reasons to believe the things I'm stating.
As an aside, are you a native English speaker? There's some very interesting cultural aspects when assigning blame. In American English, its the norm to assign blame directly "John leaked the documents.", whereas in other cultures/languages, a passive structure is more common "John had the documents. The documents were leaked." This would be a common and correct way of blaming John for leaking something in some cultures, but in English it isn't.
Presumably Google and its lawyers are primarily English speakers.
Out of curiosity if you think that the statement is true, but constructed in a way that hides information, what do you think actually happened? If I understand your position it looks something like this:
1. The four people mentioned setup watches on people's calendars, went looking for information on people... the targets of their searches weren't part of their every day work life.
2. They shared that information with someone (no one knows who) but not the press or externally.
3. The people who had the information shared with them then leaked it externally.
4. Google found out and fired the original four people from step 1 and wrote a memo deliberately masking step 2.
It's possible the above is accurate (please let me know if I got your position incorrect), but I don't think the wording of Google's announcement alone is enough to prove that. I'm apt to take it at its face value, especially because step 1 is by far the worst part in my mind and that doesn't seem to be in doubt.
That's why I'm curious if you have some inside knowledge or something (your bio says you work at Google).