I too find it bewildering to uncover the truth when there's evidence on both sides; that's why I made https://en.howtruthful.com/
"Is Hillary a bad person?" asks an opinion and has no objectively wrong answer.
"Did Hillary run a child abuse ring from a pizza parlor?" is objectively either true or false regardless of how many people believe it.
Relativism may have started with the intent of pointing out this distinction (eg the 19th century firm belief that "Primitive societies are bad") before being over generalized.