That article states they outperformed when measured over a 10, 15, 20, and 25 year period and underperformed over a 5 year period. (See the table. The longer periods include the more recent periods meaning they had strong outperformance early that more than made up for the recent under.)
Is that evidence that they’re dramatically underperforming? It seems the story is mixed and you could argue either way depending on whether you think the last 5 years are more important than the prior 20 or not. (It might be, if you argue that something fundamental changed. That would fall into the “this time it’s different” which is generally falsified eventually.)