I took a class from John White at UCONN. He gave us a couple dozen CS papers at the start of the year. Every class had 3 paper presentations, 20 minutes each. A random student was picked for each presentation.
So you had to read and understand each of the upcoming 3 papers because there was a random chance you would have to present one of the three.
The result is that you eventually read all of the papers well enough that you could give a 20 minute presentation.
There were no grades. It was pass/fail.
It was one of the best classes I ever took.