That's cool - I'd hope that's generally the case. This could also be more evidence that it is an exposure issue and it takes longer for them to catch up.
I'd be curious to ask adults that were homeschooled if they would want to do the same for their kids.
I'd wonder even if it's the common case they end up perfectly normal adults if it's hard for them prior to that.
I think I'd be nervous about being able to do it effectively for my own kids (both for the social and academic reasons).
That doesn't mean I don't think it's a solvable problem and there is probably a way to create a community of people to do this well, but that might just end up looking like a secular private school.