But it's mostly subjective.
They also serve meat (including veal) in the cafes. Some find that pretty bad.
Are web ads evil? Some will say yes for the intrusion, or the interruption, or the compound effect of all the ads people see in they're lives. All valid reasons.
Is weapons research evil? Hurts people in new ways, also can deter violence and defend from bad guys.
But, can we say without hesitation that it's just as evil as helping ICE break up families, or helping Chinese censorship?
People joined Google knowing about the ads (and the meat) but didn't expect other stuff they're seeing now. And that's perfectly reasonable.
Few firms (any?) pass every possible "not evil test," so let's strengthen the quality of the debate here by avoiding logical sloppiness that would invalidate the important questions being discussed.
It's entirely possible to run ads based on what might be of interest to someone reading that particular content without spying on users.
It's just not as profitable.
It's almost tautologically obvious that the more you know about someone, the more likely you can predict what might be of interest to them. If you don't believe me, try selling something with ads sometime. Even with all the tools Google and Facebook offer, it's hard.
There is no magic universe where you can get perfectly tailored ads along with perfect anonymity.
No, perfectly targeted advertising is actually very easy. You just place the ad in a topically appropriate place. Selling sports equipment? Put an ad on a site dedicated to that sport, problem solved. And zero tracking required.
That's not what they said, and I don't think it's what they meant. Seems they meant to point out that one can run ads simply based on product rather than user: e.g., if I'm buying a hammer, it's reasonable to show me an ad for a box of nails. It won't be perfectly tailored to the individual, but that's not the point.
It’s a great way to “other” a group or idea, signal tribal loyalty and feel good about oneself for having superior moral values.
It’s much harder to recognize that things are not a binary good/evil, they are a sliding scale as you mentioned.
"negative" itself is a loaded word because why can't it be positive instead?
etc.
In some cases, like this one, usage of the word "evil" is not implausible. The tribes already exist here, regardless of the verbage being used.
Sure there's the elephant in the room but all that still sounds pretty good. Is it right to call that a lie?