(I’m aware this lawsuit isn’t about copyright, I’m just curious)
(I’m aware this lawsuit isn’t about copyright, I’m just curious)
Genius doesn’t have a copyright claim because it doesn’t own the lyrics. Both Genius and Google hold licenses from music publishers to print song lyrics, which makes the lawsuit trickier, focusing more on how Google and its partners got the lyrics to begin with.
https://www.theverge.com/2019/12/3/20993621/genius-google-la...
I offer that to correct a mistake, knowing it doesn't invalidate your point. Reading the complaint, it sounds like it's a ToS violation. The interesting thing is that Google -> Genius have some business agreements (Genius is an adsense customer, at the least).
To my Not A Lawyer brain, that moves it out of the "scraping public documents is fine" and into a more complicated relationship. The outcome of this lawsuit will be interesting!
Just having a license doesn't necessarily give you the actual lyrics though. They still have to create or buy them from somebody.
In the past I think LyricFind said that when they licensed lyrics, some were provided by the publisher and it was the publisher that scraped them from Genius. I may be mis-remembering that, but there was something along those lines.
I think this is an issue of Genius alleging that LyricFind scraped their website with is a ToS violation.