I prefer semver, but it's still not exactly what I want. What I'm looking for is the answer to 'how painful/risky is upgrading likely to be?'. I expect an x.x.1 release to be zero/low risk - small fixes only within current api and contract. I expect a 2.x.x release to come with major risk of breakage (and I'll almost always want to wait for 2.0.2-2.0.3 before actually upgrading - and I expect a 1.x.x -> 2.x.x release to have a risk of bigger changes compared to a 5.x.x -> 6.x.x since the latter is expected to have the fundamentals ironed out by now). But there doesn't seem to be much consensus on whether an x.1.x release can have breaking changes or not - or maybe they don't come with as strict a definition of a breaking change as Shopify is using - so I'm left with treating them the same as 2.x.x (though usually I don't wait for x.x.1 in this case).