I’m asking questions because we provide tools that standardize the API development experience. Semver is trustable if the tools create the contract instead of the developer that decides to build the API. We deliver the tools that create the contract.
In this sense, APIs built and delivered atop our platform don’t need to “encourage best practice,” best practice is — or at least can be — hardcoded in with no potential for footguns.
Your concerns about semver are well-founded. I’m asking questions because I’m pondering aloud if we can fix them and change semver — with respect to APIs — from a social contract to a coded contract, and include tools necessary to inform end-users of API changes. :)
Does that make more sense?