In both cases the regulation is far more relaxed than many EU citizens would like it to be. It merely tries to minimally protect society from the overall race to the bottom in terms of employee rights and in terms of zoning and safety regulation.
EDIT: Also, my post was not meant specifically for sharing-economy platforms. In those cases I can see the need for some specific regulation (and even then I think Europe goes too far), but just tech companies in general.
Either way, surely citizen rights trump companies rights to compete every time, especially since Europe doesn't have the legal fiction of citizens united style 'corporate citizenship'.
Then come the specific regulation of US companies in Europe. Have you heard of the so called Google Tax? It is essentially a tax on tech companies that make more than $X in revenue, which only happens to affect US companies at the moment.
I can see no argument being made for the former, other than "well, it's tough to compete with a country that does not regulate as much".
Well yeah, certainly. But then that can of course be said about anything from environment laws to child labor.
Companies are not the only priority a government needs to consider. This might be a strange idea to folks in the US.
Second EU regulation is not just applicable to US companies. It does not make a difference where the company is headquartered. A EU based Uber clone would be subjected to the same regulation as an US Uber. Given the fluid transnationality of those enterprises any differentiation would be completely useless.
Third, regulation is not just needed to protect the people from the inherent private appropriation of benefits and the externalization of negatives that a market economy presents. It is also an essential component of long term stability of the system itself precisely because the market mechanism is so good at discovering self reinforcing appropriation regardless of the impacts.
I just started a company myself in Spain. The amount of bureaucracy I had to go through was unbelievable. Furthermore, I have to pay over $300 a month in taxes, even though I am currently not making any revenue. How am I supposed to compete with a U.S company like this? I know this is going on a tangent because my original argument was about overregulation of tech companies specifically. In that sense: U.S companies are allowed to compete in Europe, which means that European companies are at a disadvantage de facto since it is easier to operate in the US. I think that providing the same level of freedom to European companies is what would make it easier to compete at the same level. Trying to level the playing field by over regulating US tech companies is not the way to go.
> Second EU regulation is not just applicable to US companies. It does not make a difference where the company is headquartered. A EU based Uber clone would be subjected to the same regulation as an US Uber. Given the fluid transnationality of those enterprises any differentiation would be completely useless.
Have you heard about the Google Tax law? It is specifically addressed at tech companies making more than $X in revenue per year. Funny how the only companies that fall under that umbrella are US corporations.
> It is also an essential component of long term stability of the system itself precisely because the market mechanism is so good at discovering self reinforcing appropriation regardless of the impacts.
This is a fair point, but I think it hinders innovation in the name of long term stability, at the expense of consumers. (Uber vs Taxis)
This is one of those things that continental Europe (as opposed to English law derived systems) handles very badly: compliance costs and scaling down. In the UK system you can start a company for almost nothing from a single webform, and if you're not trading much there's almost no fees.
There is an excellent book, "The Other Path", about bureaucracy reduction in South America as a path towards the rule of law, where by making it possible for people to come into "the system" there were beneficial effects on crime and even terrorism.
I suspect there would be a lot fewer anti-EU small businessmen if most of the EU commercial law had exemptions for "fewer than five employees and less than €100k turnover".
In all of this we need to keep the reasons close to the rules. "Regulation" and "freedom" can't be assessed without asking what's being regulated and what the impacts are on the regulated and the public, and whether the regulations are necessary and effective.
(You should probably read something else about Peru in the same time period as a counterbalance, especially given that this took place in the time of Fujimori, but the ILD work on title and registration is extremely solid and should be above left-right factionalism and is not in conflict with human rights)
Why dont you move the company elsewhere? e.g. ireland...
Your complaint of bureaucracy is valid. You should not be arbitrarily held back by irrelevant protocol. While Spain (and other southern European countries) seems to be very traditional in their adherence to formalism and procedure, nevertheless this seems to be advancing into a more agile direction.
There is a difference between arguing for a level playing field, which I support, and arguing for abolishing all financial contribution to the public domain, which I oppose completely.
As a last point you might want to look up why the taxi regulations were introduced in the first place, and how, while the 'mechanism' might be new (apps), the model has resurfaced every time there was an overproduction in the car industry coupled with an economic downturn.
Funny how right after posting this, I just read the news that France fined Google (again) [1] for arbitrarily banning a company from Google Ads and promoting its own services (unrelated to the other company). This is the kind of thing that doesn't fly in the US: If I own a platform, I get to decide who can use it or not, and it is not the governments place to fine for me if I decide to promote my products in my platform (as long as there is no discrimination taking place).
I think this kind of bureaucracy and "overregulation" (inference in private business affairs) is part of what makes it impossible for European tech companies to be among the top in the world.
[1] https://www.elmundo.es/economia/empresas/2019/12/20/5dfca947...
Hell, when companies become more powerful than actual governments, the least libertarian thing you could possible do, is to give their kingdoms free reign.
The US does not (usually) interfere as much as Europe into business affairs. I don't think that automatically translate into "valuing corporate rights above those of individual citizens"
There's a vocal group of "libertarians", the ones that veer towards anarcho-capitalism, whose stance is basically that state power is bad but economic power is just fine. Those folks may not explicitly say that they want corporate rights to be above those of individual citizens, but the practical consequence of their worldview is that they will be (to an even greater extent than they already are today), because corporations have much greater economic power than individuals.
"Libertarian" used to be a concept that was purely about individual freedom, but it has been twisted to a large extent into something that is quite opposed to individual freedom in practice.
I think my point is not really getting across. I am not advocating that tech companies get a free pass to do whatever they want.
There was a multi-year investigation by France before the fine was issued to Google.
US too has anti-trust laws much like the ones which France used here.
overregulation
Or just normal non-unbridled-capitalism regulation.