There's also a neat dispute on the pin factory analysis I thought I'd share. Kevin Carson, drawing on work by Steven Marglin, argued that the pin factory example doesn't prove what Smith thinks it did, because it neglected the possibility of a single worker batching each step himself and reaping the same benefits[1]:
>Marglin took Adam Smith's classic example of the division of labor in pin-making, and stood it on its head. The increased efficiency resulted, not from the division of labor as such, but from dividing and sequencing the process into separate tasks in order to reduce set-up time. This could have been accomplished by a single cottage workman separating the various tasks and then performing them sequentially (i.e., drawing out the wire for an entire run of production, then straightening it, then cutting it, etc.).
George Reisman, in a Mises Institute article, disputed these claims [2], saying that you can't get the enhanced efficiency this way because of set-up time, tool duplication, the requirement to do it at scale to make a profit:
>If, for example, there were six distinct steps entailed in pin making, then instead of six workers working side by side continuously,in one factory, each continuously using a definite tool or piece of equipment, we would have, under cottage production, six cottage workers each performing a large volume of a given operation, while the tools and equipment required for the other five operations remained idle. His output from any given operation would also then remain idle until he finished that operation and turned to the next operation.
>The clear implication is that under the arrangement of cottage production so beloved of Carson and Marglin, the six workers would need between them thirty-six sets of tools and equipment instead of only six such sets and would have an unnecessarily large volume of partially finished product on hand at any given time. ...
>In sum, cottage production would entail a tremendous waste ofcapital and be enormously inefficient, ...
[1] http://www.mutualist.org/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderfiles... p. 166
[2] https://cdn.mises.org/20_1_5.pdf p. 7 in PDF