0. Reposition the engine forward on the wing such that the airframe is inherently unstable and needs software for stabilization.
0. Reposition the engine forward on the wing such that the airframe is inherently unstable and needs software for stabilization.
MCAS is nowhere near fast enough to compensate if the Max were actually unstable.
Sounds like unstable to me. "I am not fat, I am just insufficiently thin".
Picture a pendulum that is hinged on a greased axle vs one that is hinged on a high-friction axle.
Both will reach equilibrium eventually (they're stable) but one will do it faster/with fewer oscillations.
The 737 MAX is longitudinally stable, but it doesn't meet certain nuanced requirements of the Airworthiness regs.
> what happens is that the stick force lessens as angle of attack increases at high AoA and low airspeed, whereas in order to be compliant with certification it has to gradually increase with increasing AoA, just like a 737–100.
Nope, sorry, that's not what stability and instability mean.
Stability means it will return to equilibrium if disturbed, but the issue with the MAX is that it requires a positive force gradient per the Part 25 Airworthiness Regulations, which the MAX does not exhibit in a specific part of the envelope.
Stability is not a binary condition. The MAX is longitudinally stable in every part of the flight envelope.
"Not airworthy" does not equate to "unstable". Those two terms are orthogonal.
Like fixing a hardware problem using software. See this video about the plane's tendency to pitch up at low speed and full thrust. That's "insufficiently stable"! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6p5sboD2oO8