IOW we once had no employer-paid health insurance and we could shift back to such a system. All the same, I would expect a pay raise if it happened.
"History of USA employer-provided health insurance": https://www.peoplekeep.com/blog/part-1-the-history-of-u.s.-e...
Assuming the US, typically employers pay 50% or more of the cost. But the total cost isn't that much different than what you'd pay on the open market. So you just have to find out how much that benefit (and others) are worth to you when comparing salaries. Health care is currently very expensive, and IMHO, not that great. But it doesn't make that much difference who provides it. You can buy it on your own, which is especially important for the self-employed.
It's no more unethical if the company lied and said you'd get health care and then didn't do it, than if you took a job with a certain salary and benefits and then demanded more benefits that weren't part of the deal.
I would love to be able to change jobs and not have to think about healthcare as part of the choice.
I'd answer the first one, "should you employer...", as "no". The rationale is that health care ideally should come equal to everybody, including those who don't have employer or whose employer doesn't pay for any reason. That likely means that the government should be (more) involved.
For full-time work, an employer is expected to pay for your health care. That's how it's supposed to work in the U.S. anyway.
That’s the convention but it’s far from ideal. While it helps to have the bargaining power and administration of a plan handled by a company such as one you work for, the actual costs of healthcare to you are completely up to that company and you are placed in unreasonable burdens when you switch from one employer to another (90 days waiting period plus crazy COBRA costs are onerous).
Your health care needs supersede the timeframes of your employment. There would be many improvements if we separated healthcare coverage from employment.