Lawmakers Warn Against Private Equity Firm's .Org Takeover
gizmodo.com
gizmodo.com
I hesitate to start involving real-world geopolitics, but perhaps this is yet another compelling use case for a body such as the UN. Perhaps you don't trust one nation (e.g. the USA) to administer the entire domain naming system, but you would almost certainly trust a quorum of (ideally peaceful and democratic) nation states to do so.
The real issue here is that once you start using a name, it becomes a dependency. You may not have any preference for example.org over example.us on day zero but you sure do after you've been using one of them for a decade.
So the thing that works really well looks a lot like Namecoin, but not quite. You do want some modest annual maintenance cost per name just to discourage squatting on short/common names and cause people to return names to the available namespace once they're not using them anymore. What you don't want is for anybody to be able to ever cancel an active registration or change the terms or cost once a name is already registered.
You could do that with blockchain like Namecoin, or you could do it through legislation or contracts. Either way, it shouldn't be possible for anybody to cancel or change the terms of a registration for a name that's already registered, and that's the biggest failing of the existing system.
If we had a magic wand and could instantly put everything on a standardized global DSSS/CDMA-style scheme (across any arbitrary frequency ranges), I feel we would have far more to go around.
By contrast, people registering every possible domain name is never going to happen. Just the computational resources necessary to do that don't even exist in the world.
What makes a name valuable isn't that names are rare, it's that people know your name. Things point to it. So we don't really need to ration them but we do need to make it so that once a name is yours, it stays yours. Nobody should be able to hold your own name hostage from you.
See: various UN bodies
Particularly with bodies where alignments of players change, or where new players are added. Either you set the threshold too low, and it doesn't represent consensus; or you set it too high, and the body is gridlocked by minority dissent.
Consensus seems to work better when at least all players share a nominally similar interest (read: not hot-button international geopolitics).
Perhaps we simply look at China & Russia as the worst-case situations, and try to build policies from these perspectives. Would it be that terrible for the rest of the world if Russia decided to break away from the internet and form a domestic internet? Obviously, many businesses and individuals would become impacted by this. But, if no compromise can be reached in a global body, this is seemingly an acceptable outcome for all other actors. We already collaborate with China on dismantling the intent of a free and open internet for their citizens, so I don't think there is any way through this where we don't end up a little dirty in the process.
Maybe what we do is proceed with the globalization of DNS and just build the best goddamn internet we possibly can. If the dissenters do not want to participate initially, they will likely have to re-join the rest of the world once they realize the financial impact of not doing so.
I'd disagree and instead say that most nation-states prioritize their own aims (e.g. copyright policing, piracy, sanctions) above having a globally-consistent name resolution, where the two come in conflict.
And furthermore, many states prioritize their own economic development above globally-consistent name resolution. E.g. How many English domain names are owned by Liberians?
The trouble with international consensus is that is has to build one something that everyone wants.
... And the closest I could come to that would be a hash-based GUID resolution system. (IOW, something that lacks scarcity)
Also, if something like trademark law ever gets involved (not saying I hope it does) and the international dispute resolution would be really hard to automate and a UN body would also be useful as the central authority.
Finally, I think it would be good for the world if most people interacted with a UN-administered thing every day. Not really the "teeth" it's missing, but a good step in that direction.