It also rules out using ADS-B on drone aircraft entirely, which is a bit perplexing.
It also rules out using ADS-B on drone aircraft entirely, which is a bit perplexing.
Why did they bother to invent a publicly broadcast address if it wasn't intended to be used that way!?
It is not even close to easy to be able to change an ADS-B out ICAO address in avionics right now, so periodically changing these addresses won't happen in production.
When will people realize that security by obscurity doesn't work?
Aircraft using the 1090ES uplink can't take advantage of the privacy mode, because it's based on top of Mode S, which is an older protocol and never had privacy built in - it didn't need it before because Mode S just didn't include position data. (We'll ignore Mode S multilateration, which is a recent development.)
The private ICAO addresses are a hack to provide similar functionality as UAT.
> Why did they bother to invent a publicly broadcast address if it wasn't intended to be used that way!?
Because those addresses were invented for Mode S, which didn't broadcast position. It was part of the secondary radar (transponder) system, and needed to be paired with primary radar to get something useful.
Remote ID probably doesn’t solve all of these issues, but it may try to solve some around identification. I’m not familiar enough with the specification yet or how it’ll be implemented.
I work on Uber Elevate, which has been an industry partner for testing Remote ID. https://medium.com/wing-aviation/wing-partners-with-industry...
I think what you mean is there isn't a way for _you_ to request data.
I'm sure you are operating a SDR on 1090 MHz as an ADS-B receiver, but that is only half the equation. Aircraft transponders also listen on 1030 MHz for interrogations and will respond appropriately. Secondary surveillance radar does exactly this in the United States around towered airports.
ADS-B is just a dumbed down version of the Identify Friend or Foe system deployed by the military.
> I work on Uber Elevate, which has been an industry partner for testing Remote ID
Fantastic! If you'd like to grab coffee and learn more about how this stuff works (and how it should work in the future), my email is in my profile.
The law of unintended consequences lands pretty hard on government regulations -- mini-motorcycles come to mind; they don't fall into a category that can be made legal to use anywhere other than private property. And while there are certainly many products where "that's just fine", when things fall into that category, it makes it impossible/extremely expensive to get any form of insurance which could also be required in order to operate the thing in the first place[0].
If what you've written is true, without caveats, it'll be stifling to the market if it is has any chance of being enforced at all. A good chunk of the drone market is hobbyist and a lot of hobbyists have more hobbies than they have time. Unless they also have a regulatory compliance hobby to go along with it, a lot of them are likely to just give up on the whole thing.
Of course, this benefits makers of higher-priced drones meant for commercial markets. Some of the inexpensive drones are capable enough for professionals (or can be modded to be made capable enough) -- that's eating into sales of the $1000 -- probably far better -- drones. I'm not saying DJI or some of the larger drone makers are trying to game the system to eliminate smaller competitors, but it wouldn't really surprise me. The things they're expecting drone manufacturers to implement would require lower-priced drones to raise their prices to offset the cost. The more expensive drones might be able to cheapen-up elsewhere to offset, or they'll similarly pass that on to the consumer since bumping the price of a $1000 drone to $1050 would barely be noticed vs. a $150 drone costing $200 after being made compliant[1].
[0] Minibikes are a bad example, but the idea is that people will be less willing to buy/use a product (that requires skill to operate safely) if they cannot insure against a lawsuit when it hurts someone/causes some other form of harm that a lawyer can profitably latch onto.
[1] Hypothetical prices, obviously -- I don't understand everything that will be required nor who would be required to comply. I.e. If you can't sell non-compliant models, it'll bump up the price. If you can, it'll bump up the cost of ownership for those who aren't interested in explaining themselves to a judge/officer.
Well, given that we continue to have fire control flights grounded because of idiots flying drones, the FAA is going to keep ratcheting up the regulations until that stops.
So, either people can start getting on board with some tracking and actually provide some useful feedback and advice, or the FAA is eventually just going to ban all drones and make it a major felony to possess one.
There are concerns about overwhelming the ADS-B spectrum with a bunch of drones. It's not ruled out entirely--there are exceptions--but they want to avoid a whole bunch of drones using it, yes.
There's no putting the genie back in the bottle, so any proposal needs to scale across the widest range of UAS, while coping with potentially exponential vehicle count growth, while avoiding adverse impacts to any legacy systems (existing ATC instruments or RF networks).
That's no trivial circle to square.
By offloading performance demands onto clearing houses, they gain scalability. By avoiding existing devices, they avoid negatively impacting legacy traffic.
I'd imagine existing flight instruments wouldn't be too happy if I 100x'd the amount of data they're receiving (assuming the spectrum would even support it).
So yes, additional requirements, but that's how you get to a world where there are safely 1000s of drones in any given airspace.
Local broadcast might make it easier to identify drones which are behaving badly. For example if you have many drones operating in area, maybe you could catch the ID of specific drone using directional antenna.
Ergo, trying to keep the most numerous systems (smaller UAVs) from needing to actively broadcast seems like a good idea.
Remember that one of the reasons cell phones were originally prohibited from planes was due to signal propagation (back when they used higher power to broadcast).
Frequency isn't infinite, and a 250' tall transmitter covers a very different amount of area than one at ground level.
Seriously, your viewpoint and knowledge is EXACTLY what they want to hear.