Anybody care to chime in with some citations supporting/refuting this?
I found: http://gigaom.com/apple/mac-lands-one-two-punch-against-pcs-...
But it's a little confusing. It says Apple's unit share is between 4% and 5%, but what they call its profit share is its share of revenues, which depending on how you count seems to be 20%-25%. Given that Apple's profit margins are higher than PC manufacturers, Apple's share of the profits has to be higher than its share of revenues.
This is actually astounding, it's the opposite of what you might naively assume: In most markets, you would expect the revenue leader to be the one with the lowest prices and thinnest margins who tries to "make it up on volume."
Apple has either slightly more or approximately the same revenues as Dell and HP, while selling half as many computers at (obviously) higher prices and higher margins.
Is that your metric for "winning?"
You asked other people what they mean by winning. If you want to have a productive conversation, I suggest you ensure that your definition of winning matches theirs. Otherwise, there will only be confusion.
If in the end the one who adds bloatwares makes more money, I have to give it to them, right?
Maybe I am understanding it all wrong.
I also disagree with the logic a bit. Where's the tipping point? At what percentage market share does it become difficult to gain more?
Just a suggestion, but if you try to flesh out your queries a bit more you may find them more likely to be answered. Not your fault, but when every other poster is being ironic/sarcastic/sardonic, you have to take the extra step to make sure you're not mistaken for one of them :)