The market doesn't work because its unbalanced. For example on a dating site where women do not reach out to men, the women will complain about the low quality, and the men has to mass message. Leading to very few matches.
It the employer would however actively search for candidates the market would be more balanced, and lead to more matches.
The problem is that instead of looking themselves, employers use recruiters. What if there would be recruiters in the dating market. That wouldn't work at all. You would tell the recruiter that you want someone that is intelligent and kind. But you still dont get any matches. Because you dont know what you want until you see it.
Im thinking of like an expo where workers show their skills and portfolios and the employees show what they are working on and the problems they are solving.
Remember: If they are able to hire you without a recruiter they save a LOT of money, so they WANT you to apply directly.
Btw: The problematic mass-appliers I was refering to are the ones that apply to every damn job on the entire website. Yes, we have those. No, I don't understand their motives either. The only thing they achieve is work for the job site and the HR department, ultimately resulting in the usage of automated pre-filtering that also harms actual applicants.