Do you happen to know whether there's any McCLIM library that works on Windows with SBCL?
One idea has been to use a common low level interface such as SDL to implement a backend, which would then be very easy to get to work on Windows. Like you said, some Windows developers would have to provide input as to which one would be the most appropriate.
Note that sbcl is just another Common Lisp implementation, you could use others as well.